The single most useful thing to know when tank shopping is that the number on the box is not the number that matters. Tanks are sold by total volume, but what you actually get between pump cycles is drawdown, which is a fraction of it and varies with the model and your switch range.
Two tanks both labeled 32 gallons can deliver very different amounts of usable water. Compare drawdown.
Most of what’s on this page comes down to two things you can check yourself, today, for almost nothing:
Measure your pressure before you buy anything
Screw a gauge onto an outside tap and open it fully. The reading is the first thing a plumber will ask you for, and it rules out most of the causes on this page on its own.
A pressure gauge is an inexpensive hardware-store part.
Turn the reading into a decision
Two calculators do the arithmetic: what your pre-charge should be, and whether your tank is big enough for the pump you already have.
Open the calculator →